Head Coaching Hires
As NFL teams search for new leadership, not every coaching change results in instant success. However, franchises hope to find a gem like Ben Johnson, Mike Vrabel, or Liam Coen, whose tenures brought swift turnarounds. While it’s too early to judge all the new hires, we can evaluate them based on their fit, track record, and team situations.
New York Giants: John Harbaugh
Landing John Harbaugh was the best move the Giants could have made. It’s the franchise’s best hire since Tom Coughlin in 2004, and they can only hope for similar results. Harbaugh boasts a 61.4% career win percentage and a Super Bowl ring. Though his playoff success has waned in recent years, the Giants have struggled just as much. With recent coaching missteps behind them, Harbaugh’s presence raises expectations in New York. He’s a proven winner with a talented young core to work with.
Grade: A+
Atlanta Falcons: Kevin Stefanski
Kevin Stefanski brings two NFL Coach of the Year awards and the promise of elevating the Falcons. Despite a challenging quarterback situation, Stefanski has proven his ability to lead a team through adversity, as seen in Cleveland. With a talented roster and a weaker division, Stefanski should make an immediate impact.
Grade: A
Miami Dolphins: Jeff Hafley
Miami made a solid hire with Jeff Hafley, who earned recognition after successful seasons as the Packers’ defensive coordinator. Though Hafley inherits a tough situation, including uncertainty at quarterback and salary cap issues, his previous experience should help him navigate potential growing pains as the Dolphins rebuild.
Grade: B
Tennessee Titans: Robert Saleh
Saleh’s tenure with the New York Jets was less than stellar, but his success as the San Francisco 49ers’ defensive coordinator re-established his reputation. With strong leadership and defensive expertise, Saleh is an ideal fit for the Titans, who are in need of a turnaround. The success of his offensive staff will be crucial for future development, especially with high expectations for the 2025 draft pick, Cam Ward.
Grade: B+
Baltimore Ravens: Jesse Minter
The Ravens made a smart choice in hiring Jesse Minter, a rising star in the coaching world. Minter brings a wealth of experience, including his time as Michigan’s defensive coordinator, where he led the team to a national championship. Though this is his first head coaching role, his track record with the Los Angeles Chargers’ defense makes him a promising fit for a Ravens team looking to contend for a Super Bowl next season.
Grade: A-
Coordinator Hires
Detroit Lions: Drew Petzing
Petzing’s hire raises some eyebrows, given his mixed results as offensive coordinator with the Arizona Cardinals. Despite subpar performances, there were challenges in Arizona that might explain the lack of success. Now with a much more talented Lions offense, Petzing has the chance to prove himself in a better situation. Still, this hire leaves questions to be answered.
Grade: B-
Los Angeles Chargers: Mike McDaniel
Mike McDaniel is an exciting hire for the Chargers. Known for his innovative offensive schemes, McDaniel will work to unlock the full potential of quarterback Justin Herbert. If the offensive line can stay healthy, McDaniel’s leadership should help the Chargers boast one of the top offenses in the league.
Grade: A
Kansas City Chiefs: Eric Bieniemy
After a few years apart, Eric Bieniemy returns to the Chiefs, where he had great success as offensive coordinator. Despite his brief stint with other teams, Bieniemy’s reunion with Kansas City makes sense for both sides. His return ensures stability and familiarity, crucial for maintaining offensive dominance moving forward.
Grade: B
Tampa Bay Buccaneers: Zac Robinson
Robinson’s hire as Tampa Bay’s offensive coordinator comes with some skepticism after a lackluster performance with the Atlanta Falcons. Last season, the Falcons’ offense struggled under his leadership, and many wonder if he can turn things around in Tampa Bay. Robinson faces significant pressure as the Bucs look to bounce back after a disappointing season.
Grade: C-
Dallas Cowboys: Christian Parker
Christian Parker is a rising star in the coaching ranks, with a strong reputation as the Eagles’ defensive backs coach. At just 34 years old, he brings a fresh perspective to the Cowboys’ defense. While some risk is involved in hiring an unknown commodity, Parker’s potential is undeniable, and the Cowboys hope he’s the next big thing in defensive coaching.
Grade: B
